Best Practices Made Simple
Dean Styles
(dean.styles@gmail.com)
Sooty Solutions
Burnaby BC
http://www.sooty.ca
Abstract.
Best Practices has become the buzzword for organizations
but it stands on a strong footing of Quality Management that uses standardization
practices to improve both efficiency and quality. Starting a Best Practices
process takes work but most of what is required is just common sense.
Starting small allows you a low risk path to becoming comfortable with
the methodology
.
Best is Relative
Best Practices is the latest buzz word to come out of a decades
long search for methods to improve quality by managing business processes.
It is critical to understand is that Best Practices is a verb;
it is a process that improves quality and efficiency.
It should not be confused with the adjective best in best salesperson,
best friend, or best product. In
addition best is not a noun; can you go down to your local office supply
store and buy best, you cannot get best from your local business school
and just use it, and a consultant cannot give you best.
As you apply the Best Practices methodology you will discover
the results are unique to your organization. What is best for your organization is not always best for your
suppliers, your customers, or your competitors. The construction of Best Practices is a long term process and it
is harder than it looks. Often
it will result in an immediate cost savings and many organizations lose
interest after the short term costs savings have been realized. The biggest payoff occurs in subtle ways common to all quality improvement
methodologies. Companies that
see Best Practices as a strategic methodology will often become best-in-class
so eventually best is best.
Best Practices Project Plan
The construction of a Best Practices process can be divided
into six steps:
- Get
a Best Practices sponsor
- Start
with a goal
- Use
common sense to create a Best Practices document
- Train
and support everyone to ensure the Best Practices are applied consistently
- Monitor
to ensure the Best Practices are being followed
- Evolve
and learn from successes and failures in your Best Practices
To help separate the theory from practice we will examine the
efforts of an imaginary company called Acme Consulting in their attempts
to implement a Best Practices process.
1. Get a Best Practices
Sponsor
The implementation of Best Practices requires a change agent,
someone who is willing to overcome the resistance to change and more
important someone who has the power to obtain resources and enforce
compliance. In the case of Acme
the task was given to Jim the CFO who had successfully engineered some
clever stock manipulations and made the senior partners very rich. This was an excellent choice for Acme and it took only a little
of the CFO's time because most of the work could be delegated.
2. Start with a Goal
Probably a good place to start is with the company vision and
a list of what makes your company unique in the marketplace. Acme's vision was to become the biggest and
most profitable consulting company in history so their focus was on
growth and cost control. Most company visions are too fuzzy to be the basis
for a plan of action so the CFO decided to apply a Best Practices process
to increase revenue, reduce costs and increase profitability.
The Acme CFO said, We started small with three Best Practices
to see how the process worked.
1.
Pad the timesheet to increase billable hours and revenue.
2.
Find the client's stationery cabinet and bring stationery back
to our offices to cut our overheads.
3.
Put our most junior consultants into an on-going contracts (bate
and switch) to increase margins.
After brainstorming these practices Acme discovered it
had to add two more:
4.
We must keep these practices
secret from our clients.
5.
We must keep them secret
from our junior employees and clerical staff lest they rat on us.
This is a perfectly logical set of best practices and over
the short run it should achieve the goals of increased revenue, reduced
costs and increased margins. However
Acme ran into a few problems just weeks into the implementation of the
Best Practices.
The Acme CFO, Our secretary was typing up
the notes to our Best Practices meeting and as a result Practice 5 got
violated. She was friends with
the receptionist over at our biggest client and before long Practice
4 got violated and we ended up in a pretty ugly conference call with
their IT Manager. To make matters worse, during the training
session two of our senior consultants threatened to quit over something
called ethics. At that point
we decided our Best Practices needed to be revised.
Based on a better understanding of how our Best Practices operated
in the real world we amended them:
- Track and bill all legitimate
hours.
- Make sure our consultants
have stationery so they do not raid client's stationery cabinets.
- Assess projects to ensure
our consultant's training matches the project requirements.
Acme adjusted their Best Practices based on their implementation
experience but these practices were not as dramatic as the original
Acme goals so the CFO began to lose interest.
Luckily Suzy the Time Reporting/Billing clerk for Acme became interested
in the process after many years of trying to track billing time being
submitted on post-it notes, downloads from home brew calendars on laptops,
and emails. Suzy, who was 5'2
and described by most of the consultants as a force of nature, took
on the application of Best Practices to Practice #1 and had no problem
getting compliance. Bill in
HR took on Practice # 3 because he was trying to justify the training
budget he was in a position to enforce compliance.
Practice #2 was delegated to Frank the Office Manager who delegated
it to one of his clerks who delegated it to a summer student who left
before they could do anything.
3. Use Common Sense
to Create a Best Practices Document
One of the problems with common sense is that it is often hard
to find. People often know what
is best for them and do something completely different whether it is
dating, dieting or business processes.
The trick is to get agreement on the best thing to do, write
it down and delay the enforcement until everyone has committed.
Start small, start with the obvious and start with things where
it is easy to get agreement. Delay
divisive processes until after the Best Practices document has grown
in authority and after adopted practices are starting to pay off.
Lets look at how Suzy at Acme is doing:
Suzy said, It was taking me over three weeks
and a bunch of overtime to get customer invoices out.
I would just finish one month and it was time to start all over
again. The accounting cutoff
for Acme was the 10th of the month so paychecks can come
out on the 15th. I
would put estimates in for the time and revenue and spend the rest of
the month putting in corrections. Of
course the paychecks would all get screwed up because consultants get
an advance on the 1st of the month and the check on the 15th
was supposed to be the actual time less the advance.
Some of the guys were really organized
and would send me their time by the 2nd or 3rd
of the month. The best was George.
He had his time in a spreadsheet that looked exactly like my
time input screen. He even created a little macro that would take
his spreadsheet and create a batch job so I did not have to even retype
the data. I would get his email,
check his spreadsheet, run the macro and run the batch. I could do his time sheet in about 5 minutes. If only everyone was like George.
I decided my first Best Practice would
be to get everyone to use George's spreadsheet.
I defined a Best Practice that George's spreadsheet would be
included in the Acme laptop image and another that access to the spreadsheet
would be checked every time a laptop came in for maintenance or a software
load. I defined a Best Practice
that training for George's spreadsheet would be included with all new
staff training and another to add George's spreadsheet to the training
checklist on the annual performance reviews. I also got some of George's
time to do training for all the existing staff.
It took about 3 months to put all that together.
The next month 40% of our consultants were using George's spreadsheet
and getting their time in by the 5th of the month. The improvement was magical so I documented
the best I could and I went to Jim our CFO.
I asked to put in a Best Practice that all staff would use George's
spreadsheet and everyone would have their time in by the 5th
of the month. Jim was very supportive
and added that bonuses would depend on compliance.
The next month all but three of our consultants
had their time in by the 5th and with a little nagging and
a phone call from Jim I had all the time in before the 10th.
Customer invoices went out two weeks early on the 12th
and without having to do all that free overtime I actually got time
to spend with my family.
Last week Jim asked what George used to
report his expenses. I told him George was pretty good but Angela
had the best system.
The important things to learn from Suzy's story are that Best
Practices must be documented, implemented and enforced from end to end.
The heroes were Suzy who was the driving force and a support
CFO who provided the muscle that made compliance possible.
Suzy had a lot of help from George, George's manager, and the
IT support staff who did not expect to see any direct benefits from
the initiative. The consultants
did see a direct benefit but without their support the project would
have failed. Successful Best
Practices implementations need an organization that operates like a
community.
4. Train and support
everyone to ensure the Best Practices are applied consistently
Part of the Best Practice process is ensuring a common approach
to implementing our documented common sense. Often when you start to define one Best Practice you discover there
are things you must build into the infrastructure of the organization
to support the original Best Practice.
This leads to a chain of documented Best Practices that are required
to achieve the original goal. In
Suzy's case she had to make sure that a common set of tools were available,
she had buy-in from other groups to maintain these tools, and her sponsor
was willing to enforce the support for Best Practice from these other
groups. She got the IT folks to ensure the spreadsheet
was on every laptop and she got George's manager to free up some of
Georges billable time to do internal training.
These other groups would see no benefit from Suzy's Best Practice
but without them there would be no tools or training to implement the
required changes.
5. Monitor to ensure
the Best Practices are being followed
Most Best Practices are only effective if the use is comprehensive
(if everyone is using them) and consistent (everyone is using them in
the same way). Part of setting
up a Best Practice is to include a means of measuring compliance, get
a commitment that the monitoring will be done, and ensure there are
consequences for not using the Best Practice.
In Suzy's case she had convinced most of the consultants to use
George's spreadsheet. She then
used the results from a 40% voluntary compliance to get her sponsor
to enforce compliance on the rest.
She then followed up with those who still refused to comply by
getting her sponsor to intervene personally to ensure full compliance.
6. Evolve and learn
from successes and failures in your Best Practices
Sometimes Best Practices need to be changed because they simply
do not work. Acme's first attempt,
trying to overcharge the client to increase revenue, was a dismal failure.
When Suzy took over the time reporting Best Practices it changed
substantially from the original goal. The efficiency gain however allowed Acme to
get its invoices out two weeks early, reducing the receivables, and
increasing the company margins. Suzy
had to justify her Best Practices to the CFO so her goals and the original
goals merged when her Best Practices were implemented. Just as failure causes us to change our Best Practices; successes
also open up new opportunities. Suzy's
success with time reporting opened up the opportunity to apply Best
Practices to expense reporting.
A changing business environment will also require changes in
Best Practices. A year after
Acme implemented Suzy's time reporting Best Practices they purchased
a time reporting system that allowed consultants to use the web to enter
their own time. The Best Practices
had to be changed during the rollout of the new system.
While George's spreadsheet and batch jobs were discarded and
replaced by the web client, the Best Practices required only minor changes
to adapt to the distribution, training and enforcement of the new web
time reporting tool. There was no cost saving to fund the required
changes. It was only the commitment
of the sponsor to keep the Best Practices current that ensured the required
changes were funded.
Funding the Best Practices Implementation
The Best Practices methodology must be continuously sponsored
to be effective. Often no additional
funding is required because savings and process improvements more than
cover the cost of implementing the Best Practices process. There are two important exceptions: seed money and support group
funding.
To get a Best Practices process started you must have seed
money to keep the program coordinated and focused for one to two years
in order for Best Practices to become part of the culture of the organization. There is also a problem with changes required
by groups outside the scope of the Best Practices processes. These outside groups will see additional costs
without a matching benefit. It
is rare for an organization to fund these groups to make such changes
so it critical that the sponsor has the organization power to ensure
that the changes are made.
Often the group implementing the Best Practices will take credit
for all the savings arising from the program so seed money and support
group funding can not be justified on a strict project cost benefit
analysis. This funding must be considered a corporate
initiative and the sponsor must be able to maintain funding based on
soft benefits and a need for cultural change.
Finding Best Practices Information on the Web
When you type Best Practices into Google you get millions of
hits. Most of these are just
lists of someone's best practices and without some idea of the organization
structure, the goals and the context these are about as useful as last
week's grocery list. Many more
links take you to companies that advertise they use a Best Practices
methodology implying they would be the best companies to provide services
to you. Best for them is not necessarily best for
you and they rarely tell you how they implemented their Best Practices. Others are selling aids to documenting processes
if you plan to embark on a wholesale business process reengineering
you may need a documentation tools to keep track of data you collect
on the business objects in your organization and the transactions. Clearly finding good implementation information
on Best Practices is a needle in a haystack problem.
Benchmarking and Best Practices
There is a large body of information on benchmarking which
is closely related to Best Practices.
Benchmarking tries to match processes in one organization with
similar processes in a different organization.
The matched processes are compared and the best process is used. This works well if you are a government with
two 200 bed hospitals in different cities.
In this case they have all the data they need and the business
processes are identical. If
you tried to do benchmarking between one of the 200 bed hospitals and
local used car dealership you would discover the business processes
would not line up and choosing the best practices would be impossible.
If you have two branch offices in different cities benchmarking
can be very effective because you have all the data and the processes
match. If you try to benchmark against your competitor
you have two problems; it is very difficult to get the data and if you
actual succeed in matching you business processes to theirs you probably
lose your competitive advantage. Start
with: http://www.gao.gov/bestpractices,
familiarize yourself with the terminology and google the keywords to
find lots of excellent information on benchmarking.
Business Process Reengineering (BPR) and Best Practices
BPR assumes your business is built from Lego bricks. You take all the pieces apart (these are the
business objects), you document their properties (these are the business
data stores or member data in OO analysis), and you document where they
are and what they are connected to (business transactions or methods
in OO analysis). Even small businesses have a large number of
business objects and an even larger number of transactions. To keep track of everything you cannot just
write things down in a text document you must use a graphical tool. There are dozens of good tools available and
lots of consulting firms ready to do the object orientated analysis
to populate the tool database.
By now two things should be clear; you cannot do this yourself
you need to hire outside help and BPR is going to cost a lot of money.
Not only is the analysis expensive once you have the data in
the BPR tool you then reengineer your organization one Lego brick at
a time. The real costs show
up when you put your organization back together using the new more efficient
design. In the right organization
the improvement is nothing short of magical. In most organizations there is a huge emotional
investment in the old design which means the BPR analysts are often
given incomplete of misleading data and cultural inertia prevents a
full implementation of the new design.
The implementation then creates a hybrid between old in new that
may or may not be more efficient than the old design.
Where Best Practices comes in is choosing the new BPR design.
If you have all the business processes documented it is easy
to redesign based on the best practices. The best practices can be chosen from those
used by different groups in the organization.
The real value of BPR consultants is that they can bring knowledge
of best practices for other organizations they have reengineered. This is not really benchmarking you are actually
buying wisdom so you have to be very careful choosing the consulting
firm if you want your BPR to succeed.
Start with: http://www.defenselink.mil/nii/org/bpr.html
for a government view of BPR and for a more general view read some of
the library articles on: http://www.bpmi.org/library.esp.
Parting Thoughts
If you really need shake up your organization and can afford
the costs you will get results faster with a BPR approach. The BPR process is revolutionary and the agents
of the revolution are critical to its success. Find a large consulting firm that has a good verifiable track record,
get an enforceable cost estimate and be ruthless about staying on budget.
Best Practices can also be implemented by starting small, using
your own staff to do most of the work, and identifying business processes
that will yield early successes. You
probably need some help to get started and someone to promote the Best
Practices methodology until it becomes part of your organization's culture.
Once a Best Practices approach has demonstrated some early successes
it is easy for your trained staff to apply the methodology to other
areas in your organization. This is an evolutionary low risk path to improved
quality and efficiency.
|